The Reason Files
  • Home
  • About
  • The Gospel
    • The Gospel Blog
  • Blog
    • Christian Persecution in America
  • Encyclopedia
  • Extras!
    • Free Downloads
    • Meme Gallery >
      • Meme Gallery Page 2
      • Meme Gallery Page 3
    • Links

Atheist Argument #1: If God is Real, He Would Not Slaughter Millions of People, or Condemn People to Hell

4/25/2017

4 Comments

 
Picture
Atheist Argument #1 - If God is real, He would not slaughter millions of people or condemn people to hell

If God is real, argue the atheists, then He would be Omniscient, Omnipotent and Omnibenificient; and as such, He would not slaughter millions of people (as in the flood), He would not command the genocide of entire groups of people, and He would not condemn people to an eternal torture in hell simply because they do not follow or believe in Him. If such a God exists that does all of these things, then He is not worthy of worship, praise, or followers.

While at first glance this argument seems both logical and sound, it is based on assumptions and presuppositions that are not necessarily true. Let's look at the basic premises of this argument.

Premise #1: If God is real, He would be all-knowing, all-powerful, and all-loving.

Premise #2: If God is all-knowing, all-powerful, and all loving, then He would neither slaughter innocent people, nor would He command or allow the slaughtering of people.

Premise #3: God has both commanded the slaughter and Himself slaughtered millions of people throughout history.

Conclusion: God is either not real, or, if He is real, He is not worthy of worship, praise, or following.

As I pointed out, it is based on assumptions and presuppositions. The presuppositional bias of the atheist is that there is no God. Therefore, every one of his arguments is based on that presupposition, and that, in turn, causes the atheist to make assumptions that are not based on an accurate view of God. In this situation, God is assumed to be all-knowing, all-powerful, and all-loving. And He is. However, He is much more than that. God is also all-holy, all-righteous, all-just. He is the epitome of these various attributes, the standard of measure for them you might say.

In the argument posed by the atheist, he leaves these other attributes out of his description of God, thus describing a god that is not the God of the Bible, and then arguing against the god of his creation. This is a typical straw man argument posed by atheists.

Additionally, in order to make this argument, the atheist must ignore both the immediate context of the passage(s) he uses to support his argument (usually Genesis 5:32-10:1 [the Noahic flood], 1 Samuel 15 [the Amalekite genocide], Numbers 31 [the Midianite massacre] – there are others, but these are the most common), and also the overall context of the passage(s).

In taking these passages out of their proper context, the atheist implies in his argument that God's actions in these instances was arbitrary and capricious, the actions of a petulant 5-year old burning ants with a magnifying glass (as one atheist put it), rather than a loving God. The reality of these situations as clearly presented within the context of the passages, however, presents a completely different story.

As noted above, while God is all-loving, He is also completely holy, just and righteous. He is the one who established those character attributes. In other words, He defines morality. He determines what is holy, just and righteous, and what is not. He determines what is right and good, and what is wrong and evil.

In every instance noted in the “genocide” passages brought up by atheists to support their premises, those who were killed were not killed simply because God woke up in a bad mood and decided to kill a bunch of people. There was no capriciousness involved in God's decisions. There was justice. Those who were killed were suffering the wrath of a righteous holy God who had allowed them every opportunity to stop their evil and repent of it. But they chose not to. Instead, they made the conscious decision to continue living in the most based of depravities. They were, in each instance, wantonly engaging in the most wicked of sins. They were engaging in rampant idol worship, prostitution (that involved children), pedophilia, rape, bestiality, homosexuality – including ritualistic homosexuality with children, drunken orgies, and child sacrifice which involved the burning alive of babies and toddlers.

These people were warned by God to stop living in wanton, gross sin; and, they were warned for years – for 120 years in the case of the Noahic flood. They knew what they were doing was displeasing to God, they knew what the ultimate consequence would be, and yet they either chose to ignore the warnings, or they chose to not believe in God, thus rejecting Him out of hand. And, they continually tried to involve the Israelites – the people of God – and corrupt them as well. In many cases they succeeded, and in those cases the Israelites suffered the same consequences. As Jonathan Edwards pointed out in his sermon of the same name, it is a terrible thing to fall into the hands of an angry God!

As we all know, there are consequences for every decision we make. Sometimes those consequences are good, sometimes neutral, and sometimes decidedly less than pleasant. And the degree of our actions often determines the degree of the consequences we face. In the case of those who fell under God's wrath, the sins were not the sins of some of the people in those groups, but rather involved sins on a national level. Virtually everyone in those groups were engaged in those sins, and God judged them as nations, as well as individuals. This is what He has historically done with nations whose sin is so rampant and so wicked among the inhabitants of those nations or people groups.

And what about those who were part of those nations and people groups who were not involved in the sin of their nation or people group? As shown in numerous examples in Scripture, God removes them from the coming wrath, thus sparing them. Noah and his family, Lot and his family, the Israelites spared the plagues, The Babylonian captivity and the destruction of Jerusalem, Rahab, Esther, and so on are all examples of God sparing His people from destruction by removing them from the situation.

Thus, the atheist argument is, as has been shown, a straw man argument, and not a valid argument against God. More importantly, however, is the lesson clearly shown in those instances when God, in His ultimate holiness, righteousness and justice, endures the sins of man for just so long before man stands condemned as a result of his sin; and as can also be seen, the degree of sin seems to also have an impact on the timing of God's wrath. The more depraved an individual or nation becomes, it seems the sooner God's wrath comes and calamity ensues.

Of course, regardless of whatever wrath a sinful man or a sinful nation faces temporally, there is still the coming judgment, and those who continue to remain in their sin and continue to remain in their rejection of God, will face eternal judgment for their choice. Food for thought.
4 Comments
    Picture

    Archives

    July 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    November 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    October 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    July 2014

    Categories

    All
    2 Corinthians 6:14-18
    5 Solas
    95 Theses
    Aaron Thompson
    Abuse
    Agnosticism
    Alistair Begg
    Amber Guyger
    A Mighty Fortress Is Our God
    Angelic Revelations
    Angels
    Anne Graham Lotz
    An Open Letter To My Family And Friends
    Antinomianism
    Antiochian Orthodox
    Apocrypha
    Apologetics
    Apostasy
    Archibald Brown
    Armianism
    Arminian
    Atheism
    Atheist Arguments
    A.W. Pink
    Benjamin Knight
    Benjamin Naim
    Ben The Baptist
    Bethel Music
    Bible
    Bible Believer's Baptist Church
    Bible Contradictions
    Biblical Archaeology
    Biblical Interpretation
    Blasphemy
    Book Of Life
    Botham Jean
    Brandt Jean
    Calvinism
    Cannibalism
    Causa Finitum
    Challenge For Christians
    Charles Haddon Spurgeon
    Christianity
    Christian Life
    Christian Living
    Christian Love
    Church
    Church Of Almighty God
    Contemporary Christian Music
    Covid
    Covid 19
    Creeds
    Cults
    Death By Atheism
    Death By War
    Decisional Regeneration
    Denialism
    Dennis Grutzmacher
    Doctrines Of Demons
    Doctrines Of Grace
    Donald Trump
    Double Imputation
    Doubting
    Easter
    Eastern Lightning
    Edmund Sears
    Election 2016
    Elevation Music
    Ephesians 2:8 9
    Ephesians 2:8-9
    Erin M Harding
    Evangelizing
    Fall Of America
    False Christianity
    False Christians
    False Teachers
    Fatima
    FBQ's
    Fellowship With God
    Five Solas
    Free Ebook
    Friday Night Lectures
    Gaslighting
    Gay
    Genocide
    Gospel
    Hell
    Heresy
    Hermeneutics
    Hillsong Music
    Holiness
    Homosexual
    Homosexuality
    Hymns
    Idolatry
    Imputation
    Insanity
    Irresistible Grace
    Islam
    I Support Abuse Survivors
    Jackie Hill Perry
    James E Adams
    JC Ryle
    Jesus Culture
    John Calvin
    John MacArthur
    Jonathan Edwards
    Josh Buice
    Joshua Chavez
    Joy Reid
    Judging
    Julie Roys
    Justification
    Kenosis
    Kenotic
    Know Your Heresies
    Latter-Day Saints
    LDS Church
    Lesbian
    LGBT
    Liberalism
    Ligioner Ministries
    Ligonier Articles
    Limited Atonement
    Mark Batterson
    Martin Luther
    Martyn Lloyd-Jones
    Mary Worship
    Me Too
    Michael Servetus
    Mike Ratliff
    Monergism
    Moral Relativism
    Mormonism
    Mormons
    Mysticism
    Nancy Demoss Wogemuth
    Nauman Masih
    New IFB
    Old Testament
    Original Sin
    Persecution
    Perseverance Of The Saints
    Philadelphia Church Of God
    Pinecreek Doug
    Politics
    Pope Francis
    Prayer Circles
    Presidential Election
    Protestant
    Protestantism
    Pseudo-Christian
    Pseudo Christianity
    Pseudo-Christianity
    Race
    Racialism
    Racism
    Ravi Zacharias
    Reformation
    Reformation Day
    Reformed Theology
    Refuting The Bible
    Regeneration
    Religious Expression
    Religious Freedom Restoration Act
    Religious Pluralism
    Religious Wars
    Responding To Atheist Arguments
    Resurrection
    Resurrection Of Jesus
    Revoice
    Revoice Conference
    RFRA
    Roman Catholic
    Roman Catholic Church
    Roman Catholicism
    Romans 1 28 To 32
    Salvation
    Same Sex Marriage
    Saturday Night Movies
    Scripture Twisting
    Servus Christi
    Sin
    Southern Gospel
    Sovereignty Of God
    Steven Anderson
    Steven Furtick
    Sunday Morning Sermons
    Sure Foundation Baptist Church
    Swedenborgianism
    Synergism
    The Bible
    The Cathedrals
    The Christian Creed
    The Heart
    Theology
    The Trinity
    Ticky Tok Toddy Harding
    Todd Ferguson
    Tolerance
    Tom Ascol
    Tom Buck
    Total Depravity
    Traits Of A Debased Mind
    Trinity
    True Christianity
    True Christians
    TULIP
    Unconditional Election
    Unitarianism
    United Methodist Church
    Vaccine
    Voting
    Waldens
    Website Updates
    What Is A Christian
    What's The Difference
    Wheat And Tares
    William Lane Craig
    Wolf Alert
    Women Pastors


    Click here to read about the Persecution of Christians in America.

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.